Talk:Monster Girl Quest: Paradox/@comment-121.216.62.209-20140822102150/@comment-64.235.154.85-20140826201050

I don't understand why Paradox would get it's own Wikia.

-MGQ Paradox is still an official MGQ game, even if it's not a Visual Novel, so why treat it as something else?

-It's surprisingly user-unfriendly and confusing to use two different wikis for the same subject. For example - would you choose to go Bulbapedia, or a Pokemon Mystery Dungeon wiki, when the PMD wiki doesn't even have articles for some Pokémon? The same would apply to Paradox. Why go to that wiki? From Google, it even just looks like an inferior wiki. Plus, linking to another wiki back and forth is even more confusing.

-We already have pages for some of the monsters and locations in Paradox. They could benefit greatly from the information they have. I am in fact very eager to make edits with new information from Paradox (Slimes love boomerangs!), especially once the demo is fully translated. I would be upset if we elected to put that information somewhere else just because it's presented as an RPG.

-This wiki already has images, pages, and information on many (roughly 200, according to Torotoro) of the monsters that will be in Paradox. Uploading, creating, and writing that information, in addition to formatting, creating, and styling the new wiki, would take more work and time than if we simply edited the content we already have here. Even if we just copied everything over.

-If the issue is how to separate the information from the original trilogy from the information from Paradox, I know a Wikia script that allows you to create tabbed templates that could help, and it wouldn't be very difficult to create a "Paradox" heading on pages when editing to let you know that we're talking about Paradox now. Also, Paradox's canon is an AU canon, I think? Which basically means that the issue of differences is easily fixed by saying, "In the Paradox series," before mentioning the differences.

Sorry if this is too long, I tend to rant when I feel I have a lot to say. But really, I don't see how a Paradox-only wiki would do anything positive.