Talk:Monster Girl Quest: Paradox/@comment-27072669-20151231195357/@comment-26979215-20160101172507

Aside from the obvious reason for wanting to hang out with a guy who just wants to talk about his scat fetish all the time, I'd wager completionism. Despite being a completionist, I couldn't bring myself to recruit him. I was even more upset to learn his character sprite is Char from Gundam in his civilian disguise. In fact, there's an entire section of faces filled with sprites for Char and everyone single one of his char clones from Gundam. I even named the folder, "My God, It's filled with Chars" if you're a meme savy person. For all we know, there could be more scat captains coming for the Char Bridgrade or it could just be a character artist messing around or an RPG maker default face.

As for Kksune's original question, I don't know how you recruit him but if you recruited him once already you should be able to do so again, unless you've headed into New Game + since then, resetting the requirements. Most male recruits have simple recruirements, Pilate save him, Johan complete Pope's quest, Samson complete Sara's quest, so just interact with Scat Captain a few times and if he does ask to join you, come back later.

Alternatively, if the game doesn't let you re-recruit male companions, that could be the problem but you'd have to test that out. Pilate has no join recruiments aside from saving him, so recruit him, forget him, then try and recruit him again. If that doesn't work, you can't re-recruit males, at least in the same new game. Heading into new game + should reset their recruit requirements allowing you to recruit them again, like it does with monster girls you can re-recruit in new game plus.