Talk:Monster Girl Quest: Paradox/@comment-27176564-20151108054042/@comment-26979215-20151108233312

There are a couple of reasons that might be. Firstly, it could be bugged. I have heard reports from certain people that this quest is bugged for them and I don't know any fixes. Secondly, I might have missed something. If you successfully saw the cutscene in the Puppeteers Tower, then you've done everything right because immediately after the group discusses returning to the Seeker's Cave and exploring around. Or Thirdly, you might not have Lockpick I equipped. Lockpick I is the Thief Ability to open blue chests. The Blue Chest is sealed by magic due to the questline but you will also need to bring a thief to unlock the chest. I forgot to add that part.

If it still doesn't unlock, I'll need to redo the quest myself and figure out what I missed.