Talk:Monster Girl Quest: NG+/@comment-92.239.0.240-20140215215346

Your arguement is quite ad hominem. Cut that out, it's a crappy, archaic way to debate. Also, try to substantiate everything rather than making unfounded claims stuck together with ad hominem attacks.

The way the game has an underlying message of sacrifice, coexistance and peace, I agree. However, the point I was making was that there is injustice and hipocrisy in the game contradicting this message, and that monsters are portrays as > humans

I think the fact that so many monsters kill/enslave/rape Luka to death removes the validity of any arguement of monsters' morality. I didn't count, but I think more than 90% of monsters do one of the three above.

Also, repentence should not be enough to avoid retribution. Would anyone want to live in a world where you could escape punishment for murder by promising not to do it again? Being defeated and sealed does not count as sufficent retribution for a murderer, as it's

1. very temporary (we don't actually know how long, but the reappearance of the crab girl suggests less than a month)

2.Doesn't do anything to prevent them trying again (Crab girl)

Alma DID terrorise humans, the storm was caused by her. The entire point of Luka's quest was getting the knights to leave humans alone

Monsters don't ask for permission not because of Illias, but because their question would usually be:

"Can I rape you, then eat/enslave/ drain you?"there is certainly evidence for this in Luka's quest, considering what monsters do to him upon defeat.

how many people would say yes?

'many acts of heroism of humans'? Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm....... yep... I've got nothing

The only things that 'might' qualify would be the counterattack against Ilias in part 3, but that was mostly monster-led. Overall, humans are generally portrayed as inferior. The ONE exception (other than Luka) would be the Sabasan King?

Monsters DO operate on the existence of 'might makes right'

-4 knights wouldn't listen until beaten

-conflicts such as plansect are only stopped by Luka sealing everyone

-the idea of being 'worthy' is often equated with strength (4 spirits test, Poseidoness's test, Alice's test)

-And the most obvious one: Luka gets attacked dozens of times by monsters (not out of necessity) who then do whatever they like to him, the 'loser'.

I do, however, conceed the point that it's pointless and illogical to force 'real world' morality on a 'fictional world'.

Is that what you meant when you said "hypocrisy does not exist in the games"?