Talk:Cupid/@comment-7805464-20150318085603/@comment-25035274-20151020212851

"...it's a bit of a stretch to assume that she was eaten..."

Except we know, based on in-game lore, that if something is killed it can be reborn (possibly even with its original memories).

EDIT: Additionally, we know monsters can be unsealed fairly quickly. The Imp is unsealed in the time it takes you you defeat her at Alice's castle and then make your second trip to Succubus Village.